Pizza Fenice | Pizza Restaurant in Pelham, NY
Proud Member of
Hours & Location
View Pizza Fenice at 304 5th Ave,
Pelham, NY 10803 on Google Maps
Tuesday - Thursday
12:00 pm - 8:00 pm
Friday
12:00 pm - 10:00 pm
Saturday
12:00 pm - 9:00 pm
Sunday
12:00 pm - 8:00 pm
Party Options
*30 person minimum
Add our incredible Salad Pizza to any option for an additional $2pp
Customized Party options available upon request
#1 $30 Per Person
3 Classic Pizzas, 2 Signature Pizzas
-2 hours of service time
#2 $33 Per Person
3 Classic Pizzas & 2 Signature Pizzas, and 1 Dessert Pizza
- 2.5 hours of service time
#3 $38 Per Person
3 Classic Pizzas & 2 Signature Pizzas, 1 Sandwich Pizza or 1 Family Dinner Pizza as well as 1 Dessert Pizza
- 3 hours of service time
#4 $45 Per Person
Make Your Own Pizza Party
Interactive pizza making experience, 6 toppings to choose from to make your own personal combinations. As well as a choice of any 5 pizzas from any category & 2 Dessert Pizzas.
- 3.5 hours of service time
Classic Pizzas
(Feel free to add toppings to your menu for $1pp/per topping)
Margherita
Fresh mozzarella, hand crushed tomato, fresh basil, extra virgin olive oil and sea salt
Marinara
Hand crushed tomato, fresh garlic, extra virgin olive oil, and oregano
NY Cheese
Classic cheese pizza made with seasoned crushed tomato and aged mozzarella cheese
NJ Tomato
A Newark classic with the sauce cooked on top of the cheese and finished with grated romano
Our Classic 5 Cheese White Pizza
Whipped ricotta, aged mozzarella, pecorino romano, parmigiano reggiano, and fresh mozzarella topped with extra virgin olive oil
Olio e Alice Anchovy
Sautéed in garlic and parsley on top of our hand crushed tomatoes finished with sea salt and extra virgin olive oil
Signature Pizzas
Sunday Sausage & Peppers
Sautéed sweet Italian sausage simmered in out tomato sauce with peppers & onion and sprinkled with mozzarella & provolone.
Italian Crab Cake
Crumbled crab cake w/ fresh mozzarella on top of our creamy tomato lobster sauce.
Twice Baked Potato Pizza
Seasoned mashed sour cream & onion or bacon & cheddar or have it loaded with everything!!)
Eggplant Dream
Sautéed eggplant with tomato & garlic topped with provolone and pecorino romano cheese.
Fenice Fire
Fresh mozzarella, hot capicola, hot soppressatta , calabrian chili , and hot honey drizzle.
Grandma's Pan Pizza
12-inch pan pizza with our hand crushed tomato and aged mozzarella with a crispy -pan cooked crust (ask about adding Dry Cured Italian Sausage to this!!)
Open Faced Sandwich Pizzas- Add $3 per Person per Pizza
Ancient history is packed with references to pizza or flatbreads some described them as a type of edible plate. With that in mind we have developed 2 pizza menus - a myriad of other pizzas that we know you will enjoy and will definitely want to “Eat the plate”.
The Italian Combo
Capicola, soppressata, mortadella & genoa salami on our crispy crust with melted mozzarella topped with thin sliced tomato & red onion drizzled with our homemade oil & vinegar dressing drizzled with provolone cheese sauce.
French Dip
Thin sliced roast beef layered on top of our crispy crust with a mozzarella and provolone blend topped with rich au jus and served with extra jus on the side for dipping.
Cuban
Our butter basted crust topped with roast pork, smoked ham, swiss cheese all drizzled with classic yellow mustard.
Eggplant Caprese
Breaded eggplant layered with fresh mozzarella, sliced roma tomato and fresh roasted red peppers topped with basil and a light balsamic glaze.
The Reuben
Stacked corned beef and Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and Russian dressing.
Hot Pastrami
Delicate pastrami with spicy brown mustard topped with homemade coleslaw.
Don't see your favorite sandwich? - Ask us to turn your favorite sandwich into a pizza for your party!!
Family Dinner Pizzas - Add $5 Per Person Per Pizza
Roast Beef
With caramelized onions, mashed potato, green beans and brown gravy.
Roasted Chicken
With sautéed broccoli, wedge yukon potato and chicken jus.
Beer Braised Corned Beef & Cabbage
With red bliss potato and carrots drizzled with a light mustard sauce.
Roast Pork Loin
With stuffing, roasted brussels sprout & bacon topped with applesauce glaze.
Sugo Domenica (Sunday Sauce)
Slow cooked pieces of short rib, Italian sausage and homemade meatballs braised in our rich Sunday sauce served on our crispy crust.
Just like the sandwich pizzas ask us if we can turn your favorite family meal into a pizza to bring back some childhood nostalgia for you to share!! (Ask about our Thanksgiving pizza)
Let Us Turn Your Home Into Your Very Own Pizza Factory!
The best pizza is always the one that you (the customer) likes best. We have always believed that. This is why we always work with our clients to tailor a menu specifically for them. Of course we believe our menu is the perfect blend of classic, cultured and crazy. We want to make the perfect menu for your event, the way you want to have it.
Using a combination of our specialized pizza stones, baking steels and portable ovens we can accommodate any size pizza party indoors or out!!
As well as being able to use your home oven, we have electric ovens available.
Our wood fired and propane ovens are only available for outdoor parties with weather permitting.
We can customize a pizza party experience for you based on your needs and taking into account the size and layout of your home.
We will even come to your location for a pre-event evaluation to find what would work best for the type of event that you want your guests to experience. Our premium (locally sourced when possible) ingredients, hand crafted dough and sauce are all made especially for your event to guarantee freshness and quality as this is just the beginning!!!
John's Journey
As a Bronx native John Gristina was surrounded by great NY pizza and at a young age he started working at his father's Pizzeria and learned the basics. He later moved on and expanded his pizza knowledge as he worked in various pizza restaurants. The next stop in his journey was opening up his own pizzerias and eventually becoming a member of the World Pizza Champions. With that prestigious honor, he worked and trained with some of the best Pizzaioli in the world. Eventually, he attended the Scuola Italiana Pizzaioli and became certified in various pizza making techniques.
Now he wants to bring all the skills and knowledge he gained over the years right into your home and share it with you to make your event unforgettable.
-
John Gristina
Born and raised in the Bronx I was surrounded by pizza, even in my home. My father owned a pizzeria, he was the one that imprinted an undying work ethic in me that has its own pros and cons. I started to work for him at the ripe old age of 12. This taught me the pride of earning your own money and …
John Hayda
Lunch
One of my personal top 3 pizza restaurants I have ever been to. I have never had Detroit style pizza and it turns out, I'm a huge fan. I can't even begin to describe to you how fresh everything is. The cheese was so rich and the basil brought out so many savor flavors. That basil tasted like it was picked from a garden an hour ago. My wife and I had a few items off the menu and each slice had just the perfect balance of softness, crunch and savory flavors. The pepperoni rolls are also out of this world. I could eat here every day of the week. Chef John takes enormous pride in what he makes and it truly shows.
Fran Wright
This place is great! For pizza, they have a variety of options, from really creative combinations to more classic toppings. They use high quality ingredients and have the best gluten free pizza I’ve ever had. They also have salads, calzones and other items on their menu. I can’t recommend this place enough!
Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free crust and can make most of their pizzas with it. They’re very careful in preparing gluten free pizza.
Katie Kirk
To be honest, when I heard another pizza place was coming to Pelham, I didn’t think much of it. I’m so glad we tried it anyway because this place is fantastic!! We tried the grandma pie, angry drunk bird, the white pie, salad, and meatballs. Everything was perfect, the pies were excellent (angry drunk bird was our favorite by far), meatballs were juicy, even the salad was special. Can’t wait to try more of the menu.
Leah Gonzalez-Guzman
I saw someone on Yelp mentioning that this place had great gluten free pizza so I had to try it. I am so glad I did! It is in my top 3 gluten free pizzas ever. The crust was delicious, perfectly balanced sauce, yummy cheese blend and I loved the fresh basil. It was so good, I barely had any left to take a picture of 😆. My husband says it is better than your "regular" dough, he tried the grandma slice ... wow. I'm so happy you opened and there is no doubt you love your craft. We will be back for sure. Thank you!!!!!!
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free options
Gotham Florist
We got 2 full meals out of 1 pizza. The grandma pizza was delicious! Yummy cheese, thick crust that was crispy on the edges. Throw an egg on top and you have the most delicious breakfast 🍳
Jack S.
Yonkers, NY
This is the quintessential definition of a great neighborhood pizza joint. Great traditional slices and inventive new school slices.
The food smelled so good the to-go bag didn't make it into the car. I decided to enjoy it on the bench outside.
Also, they have 20oz RC cola bottles... the soda is just a tad lighter in syrup and carbonation compared to Coke and Pepsi. It pairs ridiculously well with this pizza.
They know what they're doing here.
Roxann S.
Los Angeles, CA
John is personable and professional. I went in to get my Dad a cheese pizza and myself a white pizza. I thought Dad's was gonna be easy, but the well done crust on the white on display was a no go. I explained to John we get whole pies, eat 2 or 3 slices and freeze the rest for later in the month.
That's when he explained his pizza isn't cooked for "leftovers" reheated in the oven as we planned. He agreed to cook it less so we could eat it at our leisure. IT WORKED & WAS WONDERFUL!!
My Dad wasn't initially pleased for other reasons. I joked that the cheese pizza was too Italian for my Pops. John remade it without the fresh mozzarella and basil on top. IT WAS A HIT! BEST PIE!!
I'm glad I shared our needs and felt heard, seen and appreciated!! We'll be back.
Danielle M
Norwalk, CT
This place may appear like a small ordinary pizza shop, but the flavors and unique choices that are being served here are far from ordinary.
I'm so happy that my husband and I came across this place because the chef and owner John knows what he's doing. The pizza sauce is so flavorful and all of the ingredients are so fresh!
I've never had Detroit style pizza before but I got to try it from here and it was delicious. If you've never been before, I'd highly suggest picking up a menu and looking through it because again, the pizzas are so unique.
Not to mention there are also dessert pizzas on there that I am very excited to try at some point because I will definitely be back.
Chef John is extremely sweet, and hospitable. You definitely won't regret coming here!
Jess L.
Westchester County, NY
Admittedly, I wanted to try this place knowing it hadn't been reviewed on Yelp yet. I didn't expect it to blow me away like it did. And I'm not even really the biggest pizza person, but this type of pizza makes me understand why some people say pizza is their favorite food group.
We tried a variety, and honestly it's hard to pick my favorite. I'd eat everything again! If I really had to pick, the Detroit style with pepperoni was delish, and the eggplant was also notable. Great crusts and topping-to-bread ratios.
The menu is unexpectedly huge. These were just from the to-go slice options available on this weekend evening.
John H.
Bridgeport, CT
One of my personal top 3 pizza restaurants I have ever been to. I have never had Detroit style pizza and it turns out, I'm a huge fan. I can't even begin to describe to you how fresh everything is. The cheese was so rich and the basil brought out so many savor flavors. That basil tasted like it was picked from a garden an hour ago. My wife and I had a few items off the menu and each slice had just the perfect balance of softness, crunch and savory flavors. The pepperoni rolls are also out of this world. I could eat here every day of the week. Chef John takes enormous pride in what he makes and it truly shows.
Please visit the restaurant to purchase a gift card. For any questions, please call (914) 633-3332.
Work With Us
We’d love to have you join our team! Please use the form below to apply. Feel free to send in your resume even if you don't see the position you're looking for listed.
Press
Contact Us
Send us a message and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible. You can also reach us by phone at (914) 633-3332.
Looking forward to hearing from you!